The myth of “not full” blocks

I’m going to take a break from addressing objections to raising the maximum block size because in discussions I’m seeing people claim that “blocks aren’t full” or “we don’t yet have a functioning fee market.”

It is true that not every single block is one-megabyte big. But it is not entirely true that “blocks aren’t full” – many blocks are full, either because miners are deciding to create blocks smaller than one megabyte or because sometimes it takes a long time to find a block. Here is a graph I created (from Jameson Lopp’s excellent website) showing the memory pool– transactions waiting to be confirmed– over time:

Every peak on that graph corresponds to a block being found, and you can see that many blocks don’t clear out the memory pool.

The biggest triangle on that graph, near the beginning, has a peak of about 4,500 transactions waiting to be confirmed. Near the end of the graph, you can see a couple of big triangles with spikes on the way up and/or the way down. Those are places where the memory pool started to back up and a miner who has decided (for whatever reason) to create smaller blocks found a block.

In the middle, around time 00:00, you see lots of little wiggles– miners got lucky and found a bunch of blocks in one hour. It looks like the memory pool completely emptied out there (the line goes to zero).

If I had infinite time I’d submit a patch to statoshi to get a graph that excludes zero-fee transactions from the graph, but looking at the graph I’m certain that a lot of miners are filling smaller blocks and leaving some fee-paying transactions out.

And since many miners are doing that, there is a functioning fee market, at least if you care about your transaction getting confirmed in the next one-or-two-or-three blocks:


That’s a graph of Alex Morcos’ spiffy new fee estimation code (which I would be reviewing instead of writing this, if I had infinite time).

If you don’t care how long your transaction takes to be confirmed, then I agree– there is no functional fee market, the transaction spam limits kick in and put a floor on transaction fees.

But we don’t need 100% full one megabyte blocks to start to learn about what is likely to happen as transaction volume rises and/or the one megabyte block size limit is raised.


Now read this

A definition of “Bitcoin”

Engineers are great at not seeing the forest for the trees. They get stuck on details and lose track of the bigger picture. I’ve seen it most often (and have been guilty myself) when they’re optimizing something to make it faster. They’... Continue →